Kelly: Grand Jury on Police Shooting May Be Good Idea | NBC New York

Kelly: Grand Jury on Police Shooting May Be Good Idea

The city's top cop says not enough is known about the shooting of Noel Polanco on the Grand Central Parkway last week



    (Published Friday, Oct. 5, 2012)

    Police Commissioner Ray Kelly said a grand jury should probe the death of a 22-year-old unarmed driver shot and killed by police after being pulled over on a busy highway near LaGuardia Airport on his way home from work last week.

    Speaking with reporters before the Columbus Day Parade, Kelly said not enough is known about the shooting of Army National Guardsmen Noel Polanco by an Emergency Service Unit detective and that a grand jury investigation will be needed to "determine precisely what happened there."

    He's not officially calling for a grand jury probe, however. 

    Polanco was on his way home to Corona from his job at the Ice Lounge in Astoria early Thursday when he was shot by Det. Hassan Hamdy during a traffic stop on the Grand Central Parkway.

    Passenger Disputes Cops' Account of Shooting

    [NY] Passenger Disputes Cops' Account of Shooting
    A friend of 22-year-old Noel Polanco, who was shot in the driver's seat by police after being pulled over on Grand Central Parkway, disputes the police account that he was reaching for a gun. Gus Rosendale reports.
    (Published Friday, Oct. 5, 2012)

    Polanco had offered a ride to a colleague, bartender Diana D'ferrari, and another woman, who was an off-duty police officer, according to law enforcement sources. All three lived in the same part of Queens.  

    As they headed home on the Grand Central Parkway, Polanco was pulled over after cutting off what turned out to be an unmarked police van.

    When Polanco stopped the car, a detective approached the vehicle and asked him to show his hands, according to police. 

    Cop Shoots, Kills Unarmed Man Near LGA

    [NY] Cop Shoots, Kills Unarmed Man Near LGA
    A police officer shot and killed a driver who was pulled over on a busy highway near LaGuardia Airport early Thursday because the cop mistakenly believed he had a gun, law enforcement sources tell NBC 4 New York.
    (Published Thursday, Oct. 4, 2012)

    The detective, a 12-year veteran assigned to ESU, fired a single shot through the passenger-side window and hit Polanco in the stomach. He was taken to the hospital, where he was pronounced dead.

    It's not clear what prompted the detective to fire the shot. Sources said Hamdy may have thought Polanco was reaching for a gun under his seat. But D'Ferrari, who was sitting in the front passenger seat, said his hands were on the steering wheel "at all times" and that the officers were angry when they pulled him over. 

    "This was an act of road rage by the police because my friend cut him off, cut off the police," she told reporters Thursday. "The police proceeded to chase us, sticking their middle finger at us and screaming obscenities at the car."

    No gun was recovered from the car.

    MORE: Detective Who Shot Unarmed National Guardsman Faced Past Abuse Allegations

    "To pull you over and ask for license and registration is one thing," said D'Ferrari. But "to jump out of a vehicle, rifles drawn and say simultaneously 'Put your hands up' -- and I hear a pop."

    The off-duty police officer in the car, who was in the backseat, told investigators she was asleep when the shooting happened.

    Polanco served in the U.S. Army for four years, enlisting in April 2008. He was assigned to the 1156th Engineer Company headquartered in Kingston, N.Y.

    Friend Tito Cordero said Polanco returned from a tour awhile back and in addition to bartending, had been working at a Honda dealership detailing cars. Polanco's mother said she wanted justice for her son.

    "They're just gonna take my son like that ... like he's some kind of criminal ... 22 years old, never got in trouble. I want justice for my son," sobbed Cecelia Reyes. "I'm not gonna let his memory stay like this. He was not a bad kid."

    Get the latest from NBC 4 New York anywhere, anytime

    • Download the App

      Available for IOS and Android