Long Island

Jury Selection Begins in Trial of Ex-NYPD Officer Accused of Murdering His 8-Year-Old Son

The death of 8-year-old Thomas Valva on Long Island in January 2020 exposed a toxic web of extreme punishment, deceit and terror, prosecutors say. And the blame transcended those accused of his murder

NBC Universal, Inc.

It was Jan. 17, 2020. Police responded to a call about a boy who had fallen in the driveway of his family's home on Long Island. When cops arrived, the child's father, an NYPD officer, was performing CPR on him in the basement. The boy died.

He was 8. His name was Thomas Valva.

In the days after his death, investigators unraveled a disturbing series of allegations -- repeat, extreme punishment, starvation, being locked in a frigid garage for hours -- at the hands of his NYPD veteran father, Michael Valva, and Michael Valva's then-fiancee, Angelina Polina.

Then came blistering condemnation from Thomas' mother, as the boy's death exposed alleged severe frailties within the family court system that enabled an alleged sustained pattern of abuse that took her son's life.

An autopsy found Thomas Valva froze to death. He had two siblings in that home. Both Michael Valva, then a 40-year-old NYPD officer with 15 years on the force, and Pollina were charged with murder in Thomas' death. Both pleaded not guilty.

Now, Michael Valva's trial begins. Jury selection starts Wednesday and two juries must be chosen, one to weigh charges against Michael Valva and the other to weigh charges against Polina.

It will be a single trial, though, despite defense attorneys' arguments that the two should be tried separately, according to Newsday. The jury selection process could take a month, according to a report.

Copyright NBC New York
Contact Us