Insanity Defense Weighed in Racist Sword Killing in New York City - NBC New York

Chief Investigative Reporter Jonathan Dienst on crime, corruption and terrorism.

Insanity Defense Weighed in Racist Sword Killing in New York City

James Jackson allegedly plunged a sword into 66-year-old Timothy Caughman on a Manhattan street March 20 because Caughman was black

    processing...

    NEWSLETTERS

    White Supremacist in NYC Sword Killing Charged With Murder as Terrorism

    James Harris Jackson, 28, was in court Monday, as prosecutors charged him with murder as an act of terrorism in addition to the murder as a hate crime charge he'd already been facing. Erica Byfield reports.

    (Published Monday, March 27, 2017)

    What to Know

    • James Harris Jackson, 28, has pleaded not guilty to murder as a hate crime in the death of Timothy Caughman

    • Authorities say Jackson admitted stabbing the 66-year-old Caughman at random on March 20 as part of a plan to kill black men in NYC

    • Jackson's lawyer has asked the judge to suppress statements Jackson made to police, including: "I really butchered him"

    A white man accused of stabbing a black man to death in a random racist attack told authorities he'd made a mess during the killing and they'd done a "terrible job" looking for him, according to court papers filed Thursday.

    "I guess you're going to want to take my shirt and pants ... I made a mess," James Harris Jackson said, according to court papers. "I really butchered him."

    Jackson, 28, has been charged with murder as a hate crime in the death of Timothy Caughman. His lawyer Patrick Brackley asked a judge to suppress the statements because he hadn't been properly read his rights.

    Brackley also said he needed more time to determine whether to argue an insanity defense because his investigators were poring over information and laboriously seeking background on Jackson.

    Man Killed by Sword-Wielding Attacker Is Laid to Rest

    [NY] Man Killed by Sword-Wielding Attacker Is Laid to Rest

    Timothy Caughman, who was stabbed in the back with a sword in midtown, was remembered by friends and family at his funeral Saturday. Rana Novini reports.

    (Published Sunday, April 2, 2017)

    Authorities say Jackson admitted killing the 66-year-old Caughman at random on March 20 as part of a plan to kill black men in New York City. He pleaded not guilty to murder as a hate crime and murder as an act of terrorism.

    Jackson is from Baltimore and a veteran who served in Afghanistan. Family friends say the allegations are out of line with how he was raised, in a tolerant and liberal middle-class family.

    "You need to arrest me. I got the knife in the coat," Jackson said to police, according to papers. "You did a terrible job looking for me. No this isn't the knife, it's in a park."

    He directed authorities to a garbage can in a park where they found the other knife, they said.

    In a jailhouse interview with the Daily News of New York, Jackson said he intended the stabbing as "a practice run" in a mission to deter interracial relationships.

    He said he would rather have killed "a young thug" or "a successful older black man with blondes ... people you see in Midtown. These younger guys that put white girls on the wrong path."

    Caughman, who was remembered as a gentleman and a good neighbor, was alone and collecting bottles for recycling when he was attacked from behind with a sword. He staggered, bleeding, into a police station and later died at a hospital.

    Get the latest from NBC 4 New York anywhere, anytime

    • Download the App

      Available for IOS and Android