Long Island Man's Lawsuit Says Cops Beat Him 'Relentlessly' - NBC New York

Chief Investigative Reporter Jonathan Dienst on crime, corruption and terrorism.

Long Island Man's Lawsuit Says Cops Beat Him 'Relentlessly'



    Long Island Man's Lawsuit Says Cops Beat Him 'Relentlessly'
    Kyle Howell, at inset, says he was beaten by police for no reason during a traffic stop

    A Long Island man who claims he was pummeled by police officers during an April 2014 traffic stop that was caught on video has filed a federal lawsuit against the officers involved.

    Kyle Howell filed the suit Thursday in U.S. District Court in Central Islip. He alleges Nassau County police officers Vincent LoGiudice and Basil Gomez "started beating him relentlessly" during the encounter.

    The officers were in an unmarked police car when they stopped Howell for driving with a broken windshield in Westbury.

    During the encounter, which was captured on surveillance cameras from a nearby business, the two officers are seen speaking with Howell briefly before LoGiudice walks behind the car and then runs back to the passenger-side door. The officers, who are white, then appear to begin punching and kicking Howell inside the car. Howell, who is black, claimed the encounter was racially motivated.

    Nassau County Police Officer Accused of Assault in Traffic Stop Beating

    [NY] Nassau County Police Officer Accused of Assault in Traffic Stop Beating
    A police officer on Long Island is accused of beating a man during a traffic stop so severely that he needed surgery for broken bones on his face. Greg Cergol reports.
    (Published Tuesday, June 3, 2014)

    The officers arrested Howell at the scene on assault, resisting arrest and drug charges. They claimed in court papers that there was a "violent struggle" when Howell tried to swallow a bag of marijuana.

    Howell initially denied those allegations at a news conference last year, but later told prosecutors that he had lied and was trying to toss the drugs when the officers beat him. The charges against him were dropped.

    Prosecutors later presented the case to a grand jury and indicted LoGiudice on assault charges. He has pleaded not guilty and is awaiting trial.

    His attorney, William Petrillo, said Thursday that "credible evidence will show that the use of force was necessary, reasonable and justified under any standard."

    Gomez was never charged.

    In the lawsuit, Howell claims the officers left him for more than 40 minutes without medical attention. His attorneys said the officers "intentionally used physical force" by punching, kneeing, kicking, slamming and shoving him.

    Charges Dropped in Long Island Police Stop Case

    [NY] Charges Dropped Against Long Island Man Who Says Police Officers Beat Him During Traffic Stop
    A Long Island man who said he was beaten and punched by two police officers while being arrested during a traffic stop that was captured on video had the criminal charges against him dropped by a prosecutor Monday. Greg Cergol has the story.
    (Published Monday, May 19, 2014)

    The lawsuit also alleges that Nassau County failed to properly train the officers about the use of appropriate physical force.

    The president of the Nassau Police Benevolent Association did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Spokesman for Nassau County and the police department both declined to comment on the suit. The police spokesman did not immediately comment on the status of an internal affairs investigation.

    Get the latest from NBC 4 New York anywhere, anytime

    • Download the App

      Available for IOS and Android