Insurgents Blocked as GOP Leaders Approve Convention Rules | NBC New York
Decision 2016

Decision 2016

Full coverage of the race for the White House

Insurgents Blocked as GOP Leaders Approve Convention Rules

Dissident delegates said they had collected signatures from delegates in at least nine states on petitions calling for the state-by-state roll call



    Over objections from anti-Donald Trump forces, Republican Party leaders approved rules for the convention and rejected a call for a state-by-state roll call vote. (Published Monday, July 18, 2016)

    Over angry and prolonged objections from anti-Donald Trump forces, Republican Party leaders approved rules for their national convention on Monday and rejected demands for a state-by-state roll call vote, a discordant start to a gathering designed to project unity.

    Hundreds of socially conservative delegates opposed to nominating Trump bellowed in outrage after the convention's presiding officer, Arkansas GOP Rep. Steve Womack, abruptly put the rules to a vote and declared them approved by voice, not an individual tally of each state's delegation.

    Though likely to lose, the dissidents had demanded a roll call, a slow-moving vote that they hoped would underscore their claims that party leaders were unfairly railroading through rules that give too much clout to the GOP hierarchy. Top Republicans and Trump campaign officials wanted to avoid such a scenario, and ended up contending with a shorter but more raucous display of fury.

    "Call the roll, call the roll," opponents shouted. Practically drowning them out were chants of "USA, USA" by Trump supporters and party loyalists.

    Trump Will Honor Election Results 'If I Win'

    [NATL] Trump Will Honor Presidential Election Results 'If I Win'
    Speaking at a rally in Ohio on Oct. 20, 2016, Donald Trump said that he would accept the presidential election results if they were in his favor. "I would like to promise and pledge to all of my voters and supporters and to all the people of the United Staes that I will totally accept the results of this great and historic presidential election -- if I win,” Donald Trump said, emphasizing the last three words by pointing into the crowd. The rally was held the day following the final debate, during which the issue of whether he would accept the election results came up. At the debate, he said he would have to wait and see what the results were. (Published Thursday, Oct. 20, 2016)

    Minutes later, Womack had the convention vote by voice again, with both sides again shouting their votes lustily. Once again, he said, the rules' supporters had prevailed.

    The defeated mavericks reacted angrily, with some delegates leaving the convention floor and others vowing to not help Trump. Gary Emineth, a North Dakota delegate and GOP donor who was part of the insurgency, said he would resign from a fundraising operation.

    "You don't do this in America," he said.

    Ken Cuccinelli, a leader of the conservative rebellion and former Virginia attorney general, ripped off his delegate credentials in protest.

    Spencer Platt/Getty Images

    "They cheated. You saw them violate their own rules," Cuccinelli said on MSNBC.

    One of the leaders of the rebellion, former Sen. Gordon Humphrey, R-N.H., said he tried to be recognized to speak but was blocked by people he described as "brownshirts" who "act like fascists."

    Carol Hanson, an Iowa delegate, said some members of the state delegation left just before the vote and others walked out as soon as the roll call was denied.

    Anti-Trump delegates were said to be considering mounting another long-shot challenge at the convention on Tuesday, perhaps by trying to force a vote on letting delegates back any candidate they choose during the nominating roll call.

    Trump: US Election Result Will Be 'Brexit Times Five'

    [NATL-PHI] Trump Rallies Voters in Bucks County
    Pennsylvania suburbs have become pivotal to both presidential candidates to win the election. NBC10's Aundrea Cline-Thomas has more from Donald Trump's rally in Bucks County. (Published Saturday, Oct. 22, 2016)

    Steve Toth, a delegate from Texas, said he's been contacted about a push to force such a vote, but the Ted Cruz supporter said he's all but given up hope for the "Never Trump" movement.

    "I'm going to vote for Trump. He's got my vote, but not my heart," he said. "And I'll vote for someone else in 2020."

    The voice votes occurred even though dissident delegates submitted petitions from a majority of delegates from what they said were at least nine states — seemingly sufficient to force a roll call vote under party rules.

    Womack said some delegates had withdrawn their signatures and that petitions from three of those states no longer qualified. That left the insurgents short of the seven states needed by GOP rule to force a roll call.

    Trump, Clinton Trade Insults at Dinner

    [NATL-NY] Trump, Clinton Trade Insults at Dinner
    Bitter presidential rivals Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump had one more face-to-face showdown before Election Day. They tried to make it funny but plenty of the jokes bombed, and some even earned scattered boos. Watch each of the candidates' roasts in their entirety here. (Published Friday, Oct. 21, 2016)

    "The chair has found insufficient support for the request for a record vote," Womack said as booming objections got ever louder.

    The reversal by some delegates came after heavy lobbying by the Trump campaign and top officials of the Republican National Committee.

    Leaders of those groups have been allied in recent weeks as Trump's path to the GOP nomination became assured. Despite wary and even hostile relations early on, the two forces have a mutual interest in healing party divisions and making Trump as competitive as possible for his expected fall matchup against the likely Democratic nominee, Hillary Clinton.

    "This is the best possible outcome for us," said Ron Kaufman, a GOP leader from Massachusetts who has been in the middle of the rules fight. "The never Trump movement never was."

    Fact Check: Trump and Clinton's Debate Claims

    [NATL] Fact Check: Trump and Clinton's Debate Claims
    Donald Trump painted an inaccurately dark portrait of manufacturing in America while Hillary Clinton stretched credulity in boasting that her spending plans won't add to the country's debt. Associated Press writer Chris Rugaber breaks down those claims and more. (Published Thursday, Oct. 20, 2016)

    Republican aides said delegates from Maine, Minnesota and the District of Columbia had removed their names from petitions demanding a roll call — a practice that was eased by a rules change when the committee met last week.

    "I have never in all my life, in six years in the Senate, seen anything like this," said Sen. Mike Lee, R-Utah, a delegate. "There's no precedent for this in parliamentary procedure. Somebody owes us an explanation."

    Leading up to Monday, anti-Trump forces repeatedly voiced suspicions that party leaders and the campaign would do whatever possible to subvert their effort. Required to submit their petitions quickly to convention secretary Susie Hudson, they frantically searched for her on the crowded convention floor Monday afternoon, suspicious that she was hiding.

    They finally found a GOP official who said he would deliver the petitions.

    Candidates Heatedly Discuss Late-Term Abortions at Debate

    [NATL] Candidates Heatedly Discuss Late-Term Abortions at Debate
    Hillary Clinton said Donald Trump was using “scare rhetoric” during an exchange about "late-term, partial-birth" abortion in Wednesday’s presidential debate. After Clinton explained why she had opposed legislation that banned such procedures, Trump said that in that case “you can take baby and rip the baby out of the womb of the mother just prior to the birth of the baby.” (Published Wednesday, Oct. 19, 2016)

    Humphrey said he opposed Trump because, "he's a dangerous sociopath, totally unfit for public office." 

    Associated Press reporters Steve Peoples, Tom Beaumont, Josh Lederman, Stephen Ohlemacher, Jonathan Lemire, William Draper and Kyle Potter contributed to this report.