"The X Factor" Recap: Top 6, Demi Lovato vs. Simon Cowell Rages On

Ahead of next week's semifinals, finalists perform two songs apiece, one acoustic; Demi angers Simon by calling Emblem3 "downgraded Jonas Brothers," he calls her "Cruella."

By Natalie Finn
|  Thursday, Dec 6, 2012  |  Updated 10:36 AM EDT
View Comments (
)
|
Email
|
Print
Celebs in the Stands: World Cup Rihanna

Getty Images

Recording artist and "X Factor" judge Demi Lovato

Photos and Videos
More Photos and Videos

Look out, Justin Bieber--Carly Rose Sonenclar kinda just showed you who's boss.

The 13-year-old phenom did a show-stopping, stripped-down version of "As Long as You Love Me," part of the night's all-acoustic first round as the top six were tasked with two songs apiece for the first time.

"I love it when I hear unplugged versions of songs that are better than the actual song," Demi Lovato praised Carly Rose. "You sang it better than Justin did."

Paige Thomas excited to do "bigger things" after "X Factor" elimination

Demi is proving herself to be as easily unimpressed as any contest judge out there, so she obviously wasn't just slinging praise right and left.

For instance, she called Simon Cowell's beloved Emblem3, who did a perfectly fine job with Bruno Mars' "Just the Way You Are," "a downgraded version of the Jonas Brothers five years ago."

"That was incredibly dumb, what you just said, honestly," Simon fired back, having already referred to Demi as "Cruella" before she shared her opinion.

Elimination aftermath and more scoop from "The X Factor" backstage

Demi was also alone out on the ledge defending CeCe Frey, whom Simon advised to pack a suitcase last week. We agree with Demi, that the 20-year-old's acoustic performance of Lady Gaga's "Edge of Glory" was her best vocal yet.

Even L.A. Reid grudgingly admitted he was becoming a fan, but Simon flat-out told CeCe, "I don't think you are worth a $5 million recording contract."

However, L.A. still refused to hear any harmonies coming from Fifth Harmony, which, as Demi pointed out after they sang Adele's "Set Fire to the Rain," is made up of talented singers who maybe shouldn't be performing as a group.

Mario Lopez tied the knot--see wife Courtney Mazza's gorgeous gown!

When Simon insisted that the ladies of Fifth Harmony was the "nicest, most humble" group he's worked with, L.A. reminded him, "Simon, this isn't a competition of niceness."

No, it certainly is not.

Diamond White, on the chopping block last week, chose to pluck James Brown's "This Is a Man's World" out of her own personal X Factor archive, a choice that dismayed Simon, even though he agreed with the rest of the judges that her vocal was strong.

Watch little Khloe Kardashian Odom sing "Happy Birthday"

Demi managed to sit through five songs without getting bored, but, alas, Tate Stevens' good but uninspiring version of Bon Jovi's "Livin' on a Prayer" was a snoozer for her. Simon, in a diss at L.A., warned the country crooner that he needed to be in charge of picking his own material.

Well, maybe another time, because the songs in round two were all chosen by folks who voted on what the contestants should sing in the online Pepsi Challenge.

First up, CeCe did a serviceable Katy Perry on "Part of Me," but her Gaga was better. And we don't know whose idea it was to have her not sing some bars, giving the impression that she was out of breath. We do know, however, that the fans voted for her to wear color and spikes and to bring back the leopard spots, hence her everything-but-the-kitchen-sink get-up.

Britney Spears' biggest moments in 2012

"What is the matter with you tonight?" Simon demanded of Demi when she questioned why Emblem3 didn't "work the stage" more doing the rejuvenated Alphaville classic "Forever Young."

Quizzed by Khloe Kardashian Odom, Demi joked that "of course" she has a crush on one of the three guys and that a restraining order was preventing her from offering more favorable criticism.

Carly Rose, meanwhile, sounded scarily mature on Beyonc's "If I Were a Boy," but that certainly didn't hurt anything--although Demi would like something "more up-tempo" to avoid becoming too predictable.

Watch Britney and Will.i.am's "Scream and Shout" video

"Here's some advice: Don't listen to a single word this one has said," Simon told the teen, motioning toward Demi. When Simon questioned the "odd lyric," Demi reminded him that Beyonc sang those very words, adding, "You interrupt me every time I speak, so don't think I'm not going to interrupt you!"

So back into the lions' den went Fifth Harmony, singing, of all things, Demi's "Give Your Heart a Break."

"I think this song should have been your song," purred the lioness, and Simon praised America for picking a great song. (Well, what do you know?!)

Simon Cowell fires back at Depeche Mode over shooting crack

Simon and L.A. weren't crazy about Diamond doing Rihanna's "Diamonds in the Sky" (couldn't resist, could you, America?), but Demi said the 13-year-old did it justice. But was that a dig at CeCe when Simon cracked that Diamond was "in a very competitive top six, or maybe top five, actually"?

Tate closed the show with Garth Brooks' "If Tomorrow Never Comes," a match made in country heaven, and was warmly welcomed back into the competition by Simon.

"I admit I got a little sleepy during that performance, but I'm also really tired, so it's probably me," apologized Demi, who also loved it.

But that explains a lot.

Who got your vote tonight? And who do you think is in danger of going home tomorrow? Sound off in the comments!

"X Factor" OMG moments!

Get the latest headlines sent to your inbox!
View Comments (
)
|
Email
|
Print
Leave Comments
What's New
21st Century Solutions
The NBCUniversal Foundation is partnering... Read more
Follow Us
Sign up to receive news and updates that matter to you.
Send Us Your Story Tips
Check Out