New NYC Schools Chief's ‘White Manhattan Parents' Tweet Brews Controversy
As for the controversy, the chancellor says, "I don't engage in Twitter fights;" but he is a staunch proponent of diversity in schools and says there's a way to "have these difficult conversations"
Chancellor Richard Carranza ,the chief of New York City’s public schools, is facing some backlash over a story he shared on Twitter early Friday.
What to Know
Richard A. Carranza became NYC schools chancellor in March; he had served as schools superintendent in Houston, Texas, since August 2016
Carranza is facing a bit of controversy over a story he shared on Twitter about parents' reactions to diversifying Upper West Side schools
Some commenters supported the gist of the story; others took issue with the why in which it was framed
The chief of New York City's public schools, a position he assumed only just last month, is facing some backlash over a story he shared on Twitter early Friday.
The tweet from Chancellor Richard Carranza's account was to a rawstory.com piece about Upper West Side parents opposing a new plan to diversify schools in their traditionally white luxury neighborhood.
The story was titled "WATCH: Wealthy white Manhattan parents angrily rant against plan to bring more black kids to their schools."
Carranza told News 4 he just hit retweet, 'They weren't my words.'
It appears, though, that he clicked the share on Twitter button directly from the site, because that autogenerates the title as the tweet status and that's exactly what he shared when he clicked the "tweet" button. There is an option to edit the status post before tweeting and the message on his account did not show up as a retweet of another account's post, but as a standalone tweet from his own accompanied by the embedded rawstory headline, image and link.
WATCH: Wealthy white Manhattan parents angrily rant against plan to bring more black kids to their schools https://t.co/FRjqEsu53v
— Chancellor Richard A. Carranza (@DOEChancellor) April 27, 2018
And that tweet has gotten hundreds upon hundreds of reactions since it was posted before 1 a.m. Many of the commenters expressed support for the gist of the story -- that socioeconomic and racial diversity are critical and that all students are entitled to equal resources in education.
Others took issue with the manner in which the tweet was framed.
"Thanks for the biased highlights," wrote one commenter.
Pexels/CC
TELEMUNDO 31
Rick Ward
TELEMUNDO 31
Monty Parnello
Rick Ward
Rick Ward
Jose A. Herrera/Telemundo39.com
Heather O
TELEMUNDO 31
Jose A. Herrera/Telemundo39.com
Jimmy Rodriguez
TELEMUNDO 31
Jose A. Herrera/Telemundo39.com
Heather O
TELEMUNDO 31
Rick Ward
Sandra Bassoff
TELEMUNDO 31
Rick Ward
Jose A. Herrera/Telemundo39.com
TELEMUNDO 31
Rick Ward
TELEMUNDO 31
TELEMUNDO 31
Jose A. Herrera/Telemundo39.com
Susan
Another, replying to an embedded share of an older Politico story on Upper West Side integration from a different commenter, tweeted, "Perhaps it would have been more valuable for the Chancellor to tweet your story than what he tweeted."
As for the controversy, the chancellor says, "I don't engage in Twitter fights." But he does believe in diversity in schools -- and doesn't buy into the argument that some critics make that schools will suffer from it.
"This is a conversation that's happening everywhere," Carranza said. "There's a way to have these difficult conversations. As the chancellor, I am who I am and I am a man of color."
He was named to the chancellor role in early March, less than a week after Mayor de Blasio's first choice, Miami schools superintendent Alberto Calvalho, backed out of the job in an unusual, on-camera school board session the day his hiring was announced.
File Photo
File Photo
District: Roxbury Public Schools; Grades: K-4; Enrollment: 354.
File Photo
District: Westfield Public Schools; Grades: 1 to 5; Enrollment: 330.
File Photo
District: Scotch Plains-Fanwood Public Schools; Grades: Pre-K to 4; Enrollment: 402.
File Photo
District: West Long Branch Public Schools; Grades: Pre-K to 4; Enrollment: 289.
File Photo
District: New Providence School District; Grades: Pre-K to 6; Enrollment: 702.
District: Hillsborough Township School District; Grades: K to 4; Enrollment: 442.
File Photo
Location: Somerset; Grades: K to 8; Enrollment: 425.
File Photo
District: Allendale School District; Grades: 4 to 8; Enrollment: 555.
File Photo
District: Rockaway Township School District; Grades: K to 5; Enrollment: 311.
File Photo
District: Wayne Public Schools; Grades: K to 5; Enrollment: 357.
File Photo
District: Hopewell Valley Regional School District; Grades: K to 5; Enrollment: 293.
File Photo
District: Cranbury School District; Grades: Pre-K to 8; Enrollment: 468.
District: Madison Public Schools; Grades: K to 5; Enrollment: 326.
File Photo
District: Oceanport School District; Grades: Pre-K to 4; Enrollment: 346.
File Photo
District: Parsippany-Troy Hills School District; Grades: K to 5; Enrollment: 255.
File Photo
District: Washington Township Schools; Grades: K to 5; Enrollment: 332.
File Photo
District: Cliffside Park School District; Grades: K to 6; Enrollment: 287.
File Photo
District: Fair Haven Public Schools; Grades: 4 to 8; Enrollment: 591.
File Photo
District: Hillsborough Township School District; Grades: Pre-K to 4; Enrollment: 495.
File Photo
District: Elizabeth Public Schools; Grades: Pre-K to 8; Enrollment: 1,039.
File Photo
District: Closter Public Schools; Grades: Pre-K to 4; Enrollment: 652.
District: Fair Lawn School District; Grades: K to 5; Enrollment: 480.
File Photo
District: Cresskill Public Schools; Grades: K to 5; Enrollment: 516.
File Photo
District: Parsippany-Troy Hills School District; Grades: K to 5; Enrollment: 374.
File Photo
District: Cape May City School District; Grades: K to 6; Enrollment: 175.
File Photo
District: Flemington-Raritan Regional School District; Grades: K to 4; Enrollment: 337.
File Photo
District: Englewood Cliffs Public Schools; Grades: 3 to 8; Enrollment: 337.
File Photo
District: Union City Public Schools; Grades: 1 to 8; Enrollment: 369.
File Photo
Location: Clifton; Grades: 6 to 8; Enrollment: 114.
File Photo
District: Cresskill Public Schools; Grades: Pre-K to 5; Enrollment: 342.
Carranza had served as schools superintendent in Houston, Texas, since August 2016; before that, he served as superintendent in San Francisco for four years, according to a biography on the Houston schools website.
In his introductory press conference, Carranza said it will be an "honor" to serve the city's 1.1 million children in the public schools, adding, "I will work every day to further the progress Chancellor Fariña has made in strengthening our public schools for generations to come."
Pexels/CC
Pexels/CC
25. Boston: U.S. News reports Beantown has a strong job market, however, it has dropped since last year.
Pexels/CC
24. Asheville, North Carolina: The Biltmore Estate is historic mansion in Asheville, North Carolina. U.S. News reports Asheville has a high quality of life.
Pexels/CC
23. Boise, Idaho: Boise, the capital of Idaho, is No. 23 on U.S. News' list and has a growing in population and affordable housing.
Getty Images
22. Charlotte, North Carolina: Charlotte, North Carolina is a low-cost city with a growing population, U.S. News reports.
Pexels/CC
21. Lexington-Fayette, Kentucky: U.S. News says its average morning commute is just 21.3 minutes, putting it among the top 20 spots in the country for shortest commute.
Pexels/CC
20. San Francisco: Although San Francisco is one of the most expensive places to live in the country, U.S. News' report says The City is a top market to find a job.
Getty Images
19. Phoenix: According to U.S. News' report, Phoenix has a median annual salary of $47,540.
Pexels/CC
18. Dallas-Fort Worth: Dallas-Forth Worth is the largest among U.S. News' top 25 metro areas.
Pexels/CC
17. San Jose, California: It's not as affordable as prior years, but U.S. News says it's still the No. 1 job market in the country.
Getty Images
16. Madison, Wisconsin: Wisconsin State Capitol. According to U.S. News' report Madison has a growing job market and holds an unemployment rate of 2.4 percent.
Pexels/CC
15. Salt Lake City, Utah: It's one of the 10 most affordable places to live out of the 125 metro areas U.S. News assessed.
Pexels/CC
14. San Antonio, Texas: It's the 16th fastest-growing metro in the country and has shown growth in desirability among U.S. residents, U.S. News says.
Triplemint
13. Raleigh and Durham, North Carolina: A consistently growing education industry was a key factor in the ranking, along with technology and job opportunities.
Pexels/CC
12. Grand Rapids, Michigan: The metro area had high scores for resident satisfaction in the Gallup-Sharecare Well-Being Index, U.S. News says.
Pexels/CC
11. Nashville, Tennessee: According to U.S. News, more and more people are viewing the metro area as a desirable place to live. The population saw 6.7 percent growth between 2012 and 2016 because of net migration, the report said.
Pexels/CC
10. Seattle: It's got a consistently strong job market and high desirability ranking among U.S. residents, U.S. News says.
Pexels/CC
9. Minneapolis-St. Paul: It's got a consistently strong job market, but also saw a "sizeable increase" in the areas image as a desirable place to live, U.S. News says.
Pexels/CC
8. Washington, D.C.: Apart from the strong job market (third best in the nation), it has high desirability ranking among U.S. residents.
Pexels/CC
7. Huntsville, Alabama: Engineering, tech, science and math are prime job market focuses -- plus it's the most affordable place to live out of all the metros U.S. News assessed.
Pexels/CC
6. Portland, Oregon: This metro leaped 26 spots to No. 6 in this year's ranking from No. 32 in 2017 because U.S. residents view it "as a highly desirable place to live," according to U.S. News.
Pexels/CC
5. Fayetteville, Arkansas: It's the fastest growing metro area in northwest Arkansas and has low relative living costs and high quality of life scores.
Pexels/CC
4. Des Moines, Iowa: It's got a low cost of living compared with the median household income, as well as sustained job market growth.
Getty Images
3. Denver, Colorado: It's been in the top three for the last three years, thanks in part to its job market and high desirability ranking.
Pexels/CC
2. Colorado Springs, Colorado: U.S. News says it jumped to second-best this year because of college prep in high school, a great job market, high desirability and flourishing industries from aerospace to tourism.
Marcus Calderon/Flickr
1. Austin, Texas: Jobs, music, South by Southwest, tech industry growth and high desirability make this Texas metro the top place to live in America, according to U.S. News.
