Donald Trump

Newcomer Democrat Max Rose Wins NYC Congressional Seat, Unseating Republican Incumbent Dan Donovan

Army veteran Max Rose, a moderate Democrat, defeated U.S. Rep. Dan Donovan, unseating the only Republican member of NYC’s congressional delegation. Tracie Strahan reports.

What to Know

  • Max Rose, who was wounded in Afghanistan in 2013, beat the odds in defeating Donovan in a district that covers Staten Island and Brooklyn
  • NY's 11th Congressional District was Trump Country in the last national election and the president remains popular in much of that area
  • The Democratic Rose stuck to nonpartisan issues such as the need to rebuild infrastructure and find a way to deal with opioid addiction

Army veteran Max Rose, a moderate Democrat, defeated U.S. Rep. Dan Donovan on Tuesday, unseating the only Republican member of New York City's congressional delegation.

Track election results live. 

Rose, who was wounded in Afghanistan in 2013, beat the odds in defeating Donovan in a district that covers Staten Island and a small part of Brooklyn. New York's 11th Congressional District was Trump Country in the last national election and the president remains popular in much of suburban Staten Island.

A jubilant Rose thanked supporters, at one point letting out an enthusiastic expletive as he praised their fundraising and canvassing efforts.

Decision 2018: Live Election Results

Source: AP
Credit: Sam Hart/NBC

"We were never in this to win an election," Rose said. "We were in this to change politics irrevocably in this country."

Unlike other Democratic candidates in liberal New York, Rose, a former health care executive who is just 31, didn't make President Donald Trump's leadership a central issue of his campaign.

Even as liberal Democrats like Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez soaked up media attention for seeking to push the party to the left, Rose stuck to nonpartisan issues such as the need to rebuild infrastructure and find a way to deal with opioid addiction.

He also said during the campaign that he wasn't going to Washington "with a partisan pitchfork in my hand," and was willing to work with the president. Rose said he wouldn't vote to make U.S. Rep. Nancy Pelosi House speaker if elected and criticized New York City's liberal mayor, Bill de Blasio, for "ignoring" Staten Island.

Rose also highlighted his military service on the campaign trail. He was one of 19 veterans around the country supported by an effort from the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee focusing on swing districts.

Donovan was Staten Island's district attorney before being elected to Congress in 2015 in a special election to replace former U.S. Rep. Michael Grimm, who pleaded guilty to tax fraud and served prison time.

He was re-elected for a full term in 2016, then beat back a spirited challenge from Grimm in this year's Republican primary.

"I don't look at this as a sad occasion. I look at this as the end of something that I have enjoyed so much," an emotional Donovan told supporters on Staten Island. "You have given me an opportunity of a lifetime and I will treasure it always."

During the primary, Donovan tacked to the right, sparring with Grimm over who would better advance the president's agenda. President Donald Trump ultimately endorsed Donovan, saying Grimm couldn't win in the general election because of his criminal record.

For the general election, Donovan swung back toward the center, highlighting instances where he had been an independent voice in Congress, including voting against the Republican tax overhaul.

Rose grew up in Brooklyn, and joined the military after being educated at Wesleyan University and the London School of Economics.

He was injured in Afghanistan when his vehicle hit an improvised explosive device, and was awarded the Purple Heart and a Bronze Star.

He moved to Staten Island in 2015 after leaving active service and remains a captain in the National Guard.

@jerome_sheila
Crowding and lines at 72 Veronica Place in Brooklyn.
Crowding and lines at 72 Veronica Place in Brooklyn.
@pseudobenno
Crowds at P.S. 11 in Clinton Hill, Brooklyn.
Trevor Boyer
McGuinness Senior Center in Greenpoint, Brooklyn, where one voter called the scene an "absolute zoo."
@katieraffa
PS 270 on Dekalb Ave, Brooklyn. "People had to forgo their right to vote in privacy because of the chaos," the photographer said.
@katieraffa
PS 270 on Dekalb Ave, Brooklyn.
@chantelcreates
Lines wrapped around at the polls in the Bronx at PS 103 where only one machine was working.
JJ Noonan
"Almost 2 hours to vote this morning in Fort Greene due to broken scanners, many ppl leaving w/o voting," JJ Noonan tweeted.
Eugene Resnick
Eugene Resnick said there were over 100 people waiting on line in north Greenpoint due to broken scanners.
Hamilton Nolan
Hundreds of people were reportedly waiting in line at Erasmus High School in Brooklyn waiting to scan their ballots because of broken scanners.
Eugene Resnick
People spend hours waiting in line in north Greenpoint.
Dustin Tyler Joyce
Father Dustin Tyler Joyce said he waited in line for more than an hour and a half with his three children to vote at PS 117 in Briarwood, Queens.
@obsessivesweets
"Every one of these people is waiting to use the one unbroken scanner in East Williamsburg poll on N Henry," Twitter user @obsessivesweets said.
@obsessivesweets
A polling booth in Williamsburg, Brooklyn.
@obsessivesweets
Large lines in Williamsburg, Brooklyn.
@Tea_Pow
Only one polling machine at Harry S. Truman High School in the Bronx was reported to be working.
Erica Grow
Long lines at 97th Street and Amsterdam in New York.
@sanyorker
Long voting lines at MS 114 at E 91st were reported to be down the block, down the staircases, down the halls and snaking all over the auditorium.
Brad Lander
NYC council member Brad Lander posted this image from the Kingsboro Temple Seventh-day Adventist Church. "[The feeling when] it’s 12:30 and pouring rain, your poll-site is a mosh-pit, there’s a line of umbrellas down the block waiting to vote ... and they’ve set up an “End of Line” sign like it’s an amusement park," he said on Twitter.
Brad Lander
Lines outside the Kingsboro Temple Seventh-day Adventist Church in Brooklyn.
Crowds inside the Kingsboro Temple Seventh-day Adventist Church in Brooklyn.
@mattwcody
Long line in Hells Kitchen, Manhattan.
Gail Drakes
Only one scanner was reportedly working at Erasmus High School in Brooklyn.
Gail Drakes
Scanners not working at Erasmus High School in Brooklyn.
Gail Drakes
Large crowds at Erasmus High School in Brooklyn.
Only one scanner was reportedly working at the Brooklyn Public Library polling station.
Frank Washkuch
"Yowza. Lines of half a city block at Seventh Day Adventist in Park Slope," PRWeek news director Frank Washkuch tweeted.
@thejlm / J McVay
A line down the block to vote at PS 33 in Chelsea, New York.
Megan MacInnes
A line down the street to vote on the Upper East Side at PS 158, where 4 of 8 scanners were not working.
Megan MacInnes
Megan MacInnes described a wrap-around line at PS 158.
Megan MacInnes
"Four of eight ballot scanners appear to broken at my polling place on the UES. Not helped by the very confusing ballot that we had to tear and scan separately," MacInnes said.
@murphquake
Twitter user @murphquake said no scanners were working at PS174Q in Rego Park, Queens, when he went to vote. "No one can #vote, [poll workers are] refusing to allow people to leave and come back to vote again and are refusing to issue ballots to people arriving now," he tweeted.
Samantha Lee Robles
At PS 9 in Brooklyn three out of 4 voting machines were broken, with long lines reported throughout the day and into the evening.
Copyright AP - Associated Press
Exit mobile version