Panel Urges Removal or Censure of Monserrate - NBC New York

Panel Urges Removal or Censure of Monserrate

Queens Democrat was convicted of assaulting his girlfriend last year



    Panel Urges Removal or Censure of Monserrate
    New York State Sen. Hiram Monserrate

    A senator convicted of a misdemeanor assault after his girlfriend showed up at a hospital with a slash on her face should be expelled or censured, according to the report from a special committee set up to investigate the senator's actions.

    Legislative officials familiar with the report told The Associated Press on Tuesday that the report into Sen. Hiram Monserrate will send both options to the full senate for a vote. The officials spoke on condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to speak publicly.

    "This matter does not affect us. Somebody leaked something that we haven't seen," spokesman Mike Nieves told NBC New York by phone. "The senator is doing his job, moving to pass consumer protection legislation."

    Monserrate was convicted of dragging his girlfriend Karla Giraldo but acquitted of a felony. A felony conviction would have automatically cost him his job. Giraldo's face was slashed by broken glass during what both called an accident.

    Chuck Scarborough Interviews State Senator Hiram Monserrate

    [NY] Chuck Scarborough Interviews State Senator Hiram Monserrate
    The Debrief with David Ushery airs clip of Scarborough's interview
    (Published Friday, June 22, 2012)

    Monserrate is a Democrat from Queens who last year temporarily joined with Republicans to stage an overthrow in the chamber. Democrats have a 32-30 majority and conference leader John Sampson controls the flow of measures to the floor.

    Monserrate said Tuesday he won't give up his job even if the Senate votes to expel him.

    "I'm working here,'' he said, noting he would be voting and chairing a meeting of the Consumer Protection Committee.

    No Jail Time for State Senator Monserrate

    [NY] No Jail Time for State Senator  Monserrate
    State Senator Hiram Monserrate sentenced to three years of probation, 250 hours of community service and 52 weeks of anger management for recklessly causing physical injury to his girlfriend.
    (Published Friday, Dec. 4, 2009)

    His lawyer, Joseph Tacopina, has said there is no legal basis under the state constitution for Monserrate's expulsion.

    Monserrate supporters also note that the assault happened before the former New York City policeman and councilman joined the state Senate.

    A draft of the committee report in late December cited a section of the legislative law and maintained the Senate does have the authority to remove one of its own.

    Prosecutors Release Monserrate Trial Video

    [NY] Prosecutors Release Monserrate Trial Video
    In surveillance video played at State Sen. Hiram Monserrate's assault trial, the lawmaker is seen throwing out a business card given to his girlfriend prosecutors say. He also allegedly pulled her away from seeking help at a neighbor's door.
    (Published Wednesday, Sept. 23, 2009)

    After the committee met late Monday, its chairman, Sen. Eric Schneiderman, said they were close to a decision and he hoped to get consensus among the five Democrats and four Republicans.

    Several declined to comment except to agree they were close to the end.

    "The draft report has not been finalized, nor has it been presented to the members of the conference or discussed by the leadership,'' said Austin Shafran, spokesman for the Senate's Democratic majority. "We are not going to comment until the report is finalized and released from the committee.''

    The committee was made up of five Democrats, including Schneiderman, who represents part of Manhattan and the Bronx.

    Others are Sens. Ruth Hassell-Thompson of the Bronx, Diane Savino of Staten Island, Toby Ann Stavisky of Queens and Andrea Stewart-Cousins of Yonkers.

    Besides Lanza of Staten Island, Republican members of the special committee include John Flanagan of Long Island, James Alesi of Monroe County and Catharine Young of Jamestown.