New York City

NYC Prosecutor Who Was a ‘Son of Sam' Judge Will Retire

The 86-year-old Democrat spent 18 years on the bench — and is still widely known in legal circles as "Judge Brown"

What to Know

  • A longtime New York City district attorney who presided as a judge at the "Son of Sam" arraignment will retire this year
  • Queens District Attorney Richard A. Brown said on Wednesday that he won't seek re-election in November
  • The 86-year-old Democrat spent 18 years on the bench — and is still widely known in legal circles as "Judge Brown"

A longtime New York City prosecutor and former judge who presided over the arraignment of "Son of Sam" killer David Berkowitz will retire at the end of the year, he said Wednesday.

Queens District Attorney Richard Brown, who was appointed in 1991, said he plans on completing his term but would skip what was shaping up to be a tough re-election fight.

The 86-year-old has been battling Parkinson's disease for the past few years and said he came to the decision "after careful thought and consideration."

Brown, a Democrat, ran unopposed six times and become the borough's longest-serving district attorney, but he would have faced competition this time around.

The borough president, a city councilman and a former judge were already jockeying for the job before Brown's announcement.

In a statement, Brown said he was "deeply appreciative and humbled to have had the trust and confidence" of voters for so long.

"While it is difficult to say goodbye, I am comforted by the knowledge that I leave a legacy of accomplishment, excellence and government at its best, for which anyone can be proud," said Brown, who is married with two daughters, a son and two grandchildren.

Brown was never a prosecutor until Gov. Mario Cuomo picked him from 14 candidates to replace retiring DA John Santucci.

His tenure has tracked with a precipitous drop in crime in New York City and shifts in how police and prosecutors combat crime. In 1991, there were more than 2,100 homicides in the city. Last year, there were fewer than 300.

Years before a shooting in Ferguson, Missouri, shone a spotlight on police killing unarmed black men, Brown pursued criminal charges against three detectives in the 2006 death of Sean Bell, who was shot leaving a nightclub the morning of his planned wedding.

They were acquitted by a judge, but the police department fired them.

Critics have knocked Brown as a relic of a tough-on-crime era that saw scores of mostly poor minorities put behind bars for low-level quality-of-life offenses. Last fall, protesters chanted "Take Down Dick Brown" as they rallied at a Queens courthouse against what they called his "uniquely punitive policies."

Brown was born in Brooklyn, but his official biography notes he "has been a lifelong resident of Queens since age five."

Brown, a 1956 graduate of New York University's law school, worked for the state assembly and was Mayor John Lindsay's legislative representative in Albany before being appointed as a criminal court judge in 1973.

Brown served on the bench for 18 years, interrupting his tenure in 1979 to serve as Gov. Hugh Carey's chief legal adviser. He returned to the courtroom in 1981 and is still widely known in legal circles as "Judge Brown."

On Brown's first day as a judge, a defendant pulled out a gun and started shooting in the courtroom. Brown saved himself by dropping to the floor behind his bench. The episode earned him the nickname "Duck Down Brown."

Brown presided over Berkowitz's arraignment in 1977 under heavy security and intense public interest.

He ordered the then-24-year-old postal worker to undergo psychiatric testing and said that he should be jailed under maximum security conditions, away from other inmates.

"I remember the courtroom was packed to the rafters," Brown told The Associated Press in 2017. "It was almost like the air was taken out of the room when he walked in."

Copyright AP - Associated Press
Contact Us