Fired Long Island Baby Sitter Stalked 4-Year-Old Boy: Police

Casey Evans, 29, is accused of trying to sign the 4-year-old boy out of school and showing up at his house to leave him a gift

Police arrested a Long Island woman for allegedly stalking a 4-year-old boy whom she used to baby-sit.

Casey Evans, 29, baby-sat the Sayville boy from August to November of last year, but was fired by his parents, authorities said.

Months later, on March 30, she tried to sign the boy out of school without his parents' permission, according to police. 

Later that day, she entered the family’s home illegally to leave a gift for the child, police said.

Evans was arrested over the weekend on stalking and trespassing charges. She was arraigned in Central Islip on Sunday.

Evans is represented by Legal Aid, which does not comment on cases.

Contact Us