Judge in Upstate New York Sparks Outrage for No Jail Time in Rape Sentence - NBC New York

Chief Investigative Reporter Jonathan Dienst on crime, corruption and terrorism.

Judge in Upstate New York Sparks Outrage for No Jail Time in Rape Sentence

The sentencing drew national media attention and harsh criticism

    processing...

    NEWSLETTERS

    Judge in Upstate New York Sparks Outrage for No Jail Time in Rape Sentence

    What to Know

    • NY court officials say a judge stoked outrage for sentencing a former school bus driver to probation in the rape of a 14-year-old

    • Jefferson County Supreme Court Judge James McClusky last week sentenced 26-year-old Shane Piche to 10 years of probation

    • Court officials say the judge has been getting "numerous vitriolic" phone calls

    An upstate New York judge who stoked social media outrage for sentencing a former school bus driver to probation in the rape of a 14-year-old is getting "numerous vitriolic" phone calls, court officials said Tuesday.

    Jefferson County Supreme Court Judge James McClusky last week sentenced Shane Piche to 10 years of probation, sparking an online wave of condemnation from people arguing that the punishment was too lenient. The 26-year-old was accused of raping the teenager at his residence in Watertown, New York, last summer. Piche, who was a bus driver in the victim's school district, pleaded guilty to third-degree rape in February.

    Piche also was required to register as a Level 1 sex offender, the lowest of three categories based on the risk of another offense. Three orders of protection were issued and Piche was ordered not to be left alone with anyone under the age of 17.

    The sentencing drew national media attention and harsh criticism. Twitter users posted the phone number and address of McClusky's chambers in Watertown.

    "The Judge's chambers have received numerous vitriolic calls regarding the case, the vast majority from out of State, by individuals who know nothing about the facts and circumstances of the case, thanks to social media," state court spokesman Lucian Chalfen wrote in an email.

    Chalfen said the judge was "well within" the sentencing range for this type of negotiated plea conviction. The maximum state prison time he could have received would have been from 1 1/3 to 4 years, he said.

    Jefferson County chief assistant district attorney Patricia Dziuba said all parties acted within the parameters set by law and that the prosecutor handling the case sought up to six months of jail time along with probation, supervision and treatment. She declined to criticize the judge's sentence.

    Body-Cam Footage Shows Baby Rescued From Plastic Bag

    [NATL] Baby Rescued From Plastic Bag in Georgia, Body-Cam Footage Shows

    Georgia sheriff's office released dramatic body-cam video showing the rescue of a newborn girl who was found alive inside a plastic bag in the woods.

    (Published Wednesday, June 26, 2019)

    Piche didn't make a statement during his sentencing.

    Calls seeking comment were left Tuesday with McCluskey and Piche's attorney, Eric Swartz.

    "He'll be a felon for the rest of his life. He's on the sex offender registry for a long time," Swartz told television station WWNY of Watertown.

    The station said a victim impact statement given to them by the victim's mother read, "I wish Shane Piche would have received time in jail for the harm he caused to my child. He took something from my daughter she will never get back and has caused her to struggle with depression and anxiety."

    Chelsea Miller, of the New York State Coalition Against Sexual Assault, said based on the mother's statement, it's possible that the judge and court officials didn't understand the harm the survivor experienced.

    "Unfortunately, this can discourage survivors who see jail or prison time as a form of accountability," Miller said.

    Mom Kills Son While Playing Chicken

    [NATL] Mom Kills Son While Playing Chicken
    A Texas mother is accused of killing her 3-year old son after running him over with an SUV during a game of "chicken".
    (Published Tuesday, June 25, 2019)

    Other judges also have faced public pressure over sex-crime sentences in recent years.

    In a prominent example, California voters recalled Santa Clara County Judge Aaron Persky last year after he sentenced college swimmer Brock Turner to six months in jail on a sexual assault conviction. Turner denied the accusation.

    Persky cited a probation department recommendation, Turner's youth and his clean criminal record in departing from a minimum sentence of two years in prison. California's Commission on Judicial Performance ruled that the sentencing was done correctly, but critics said the punishment was too light.

    US Attorney Lays Out Next Steps After Billion-Dollar Cocaine Bust

    [NATL] US Attorney Lays Out Next Steps After Billion-Dollar Cocaine Bust

    Bill McSwain, United States Attorney for the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania, addressed the media Friday following a billion-dollar cocaine seizure at the Philadelphia seaport.

    (Published Friday, June 21, 2019)

    Get the latest from NBC 4 New York anywhere, anytime

    • Download the App

      Available for IOS and Android