House Votes to Censure Rangel - NBC New York

House Votes to Censure Rangel



    House Votes to Censure Rangel
    This video frame grab image provided by House Television shows Rep. Charles Rangel, D-N.Y., stands in the well on the House floor while House Speaker Nancy Pelosi reads the censure resolution passed by the House on Capitol Hill in Washington, Thursday, Dec. 2, 2010. It was only the 23rd time that the House invoked its most serious punishment short of expulsion.

    Veteran Rep. Charles Rangel, the raspy-voiced, backslapping former chairman of one of Congress' most powerful committees, was censured by his House colleagues for financial misconduct Thursday in a solemn moment of humiliation in the sunset of his career.

    Ater the 333-79 vote, the Democrat from New York's Harlem stood at the front of the House and faced Speaker Nancy Pelosi as she read him the formal resolution of censure.

    Responding, he admitted he had made mistakes and said he was sorry he had put fellow House members in an embarrassing position. But he suggested the winds of politics were involved as well.

    "In my heart I truly feel good," Rangel said. "A lot of it has to do with the fact that I know in my heart that I am not going to be judged by this Congress, but I am going to be judged by my life."

    It was only the 23rd time in the nation's history that a House member received the most severe punishment short of expulsion. Rangel committed ethical and fundraising violations of House rules, including submitting misleading financial statements and failing to pay all his taxes, the chamber's ethics committee determined last month.

    Before the censure vote, the House rejected an attempt to reduce his punishment to a simple reprimand. That vote was 267-146.

    The dapper congressman, wearing a blue suit, blue tie and a blue handkerchief, told his fellow lawmakers, "I have made serious mistakes." But he pleaded with them to be "guided by fairness," taking account of his long record and his service in the Korean War.

    Before that, the chairman of the ethics committee, Democratic Rep. Zoe Lofgren of California, said the censure her committee recommended was consistent with a Democratic pledge to run "the most honest, most open, most ethical Congress in history."

    She said Rangel "violated the public trust" while serving in influential positions including chairman of the tax-writing Ways and Means Committee.

    Rangel was at times contrite, saying that members of Congress "have a higher responsibility than most people" for ethical conduct and that senior lawmakers like himself "should act as a model" for newer lawmakers.

    "I brought it on to myself," he said of his troubles.

    Rep. Jo Bonner of Alabama, the top Republican on the ethics committee, said the nation's voters were paying attention to how the House dealt with a member who committed serious ethical violations.

    "I have no doubt the people we work for will be watching with interest," Bonner said.

    The House chamber was about two-thirds full. Many members had their heads bowed over mobile phones and a few iPads. Someone's BlackBerry pinged every time an e-mail arrived.

    A half-dozen members spoke in Rangel's defense, arguing a reprimand was appropriate. A handful of Democrats applauded after one of them, Republican Rep. Peter King of New York, backed Rangel.

    Rangel has said repeatedly he did not intend to break any House rules, and he walked out of the ethics committee's deliberations last month because, he said, he had been treated unfairly for "good faith mistakes." The panel found him guilty on 11 of 13 charges and overwhelmingly recommended that he be censured.

    It's a difficult sunset for Rangel's long career. A jovial politician with a distinctive voice, Rangel was re-elected in November with more than 80 percent of the vote despite being under an ethics cloud for more than two years. He has argued that censure is reserved for corrupt politicians — and he's not one of them.

    He also has been making a more personal plea, asking colleagues to remember that he won a Purple Heart after he was wounded in combat in Korea, to focus on his efforts for the underprivileged and to understand that he has great respect for the institution he has served for so long. He's tied for fourth in House seniority.

    The House ethics committee painted Rangel as a congressman who ignored rules of conduct and became a tax scofflaw despite his knowledge of tax law from his long service on the tax-writing Ways and Means Committee.

    Rangel chaired that panel until last March, when he stepped down after the panel — in a separate case — found that he improperly allowed corporations to finance two trips to Caribbean conferences.

    Rangel shortchanged the IRS for 17 years by failing to pay taxes on income from his rental unit in a Dominican Republic resort. He filed misleading financial disclosure reports for a decade, leaving out hundreds of thousands of dollars in assets he owned.

    He used congressional letterheads and staff to solicit donations for a monument to himself: a center named after him at City College of New York. The donors included businesses and their charitable foundations that had issues before Congress and, specifically, before the Ways and Means Committee.

    Rangel also set up a campaign office in the Harlem building where he lives, despite a lease specifying the unit was for residential use only.

    He has paid the Treasury $10,422 and New York state $4,501 to fulfill an ethics committee recommendation. The amounts were to cover taxes he would have owed on his villa income had the statute of limitations not run out on his tax bills.

    The last previous House censure was in 1983, when two members, Reps. Gerry E. Studds, D-Mass., and Daniel Crane, R-Ill., were disciplined for having sex with teenage pages. Nine House members have been reprimanded, the latest last year when Rep. Joe Wilson, R-S.C. was punished for a breach of decorum.

    Wilson had yelled "You lie" at President Barack Obama during a nationally televised speech to Congress.

    The objective for the House is to make the punishment fit the ethics violation. In past cases, a censure usually was reserved for congressmen who enriched themselves personally.

    Rangel was not charged with lining his pockets. But the ethics committee found that his violations went on for so long that the pattern of misconduct deserved a censure.


    The House has expelled five members over the years, censured 22 and reprimanded another nine.

    Punishments by year, name, state and conduct:


    1861 John Clark, Missouri, disloyalty to the Union — taking up arms against the United States.

    1861 John Reid, Missouri, disloyalty to the Union — taking up arms against the United States.

    1861 Henry Burnett, Kentucky, disloyalty to the Union — taking up arms against the United States.

    1980 Michael Myers, Pennsylvania, bribery conviction for accepting money in return for promise to use influence in immigration matters.

    2002 James Traficant, Ohio, conviction of conspiracy to commit bribery, obstruction of justice, filing false tax returns; racketeering in connection with receipt of favors and money in return for official acts; receipt of salary kickbacks from staff.


    1832 William Stanberry, Ohio, insulting the speaker of the House.

    1842 Joshua Giddings, Ohio, conduct related to delicate international negotiations deemed "incendiary."

    1856 Lawrence Keitt, South Carolina, assisting in assault on a member.

    1864 Benjamin Harris, Maryland, treasonous conduct in opposing subjugation of the South.

    1864 Alexander Long, Ohio, supporting recognition of the Confederacy.

    1866 John Chanler, New York, insulting the House by introduction of resolution containing unparliamentary language.

    1866 Lovell Rousseau, Kentucky, assault of another member.

    1867 John Hunter, New York, unparliamentary language.

    1868 Fernando Wood, New York, unparliamentary language.

    1869 Edward Holbrook, Idaho, unparliamentary language.

    1870 Benjamin Whittemore, South Carolina, selling military academy appointments.

    1870 John DeWeese, South Carolina, selling military academy appointments.

    1870 Roderick Butler, Tennessee, accepting money for "political purposes" in return for academy appointees.

    1873 Oakes Ames, Massachusetts, bribery in "Credit Mobilier" case (conduct prior to election to House).

    1873 James Brooks, New York, bribery in "Credit Mobilier" case (conduct prior to election to House).

    1875 John Brown, Kentucky, unparliamentary language.

    1890 William Bynum, Indiana, unparliamentary language.

    1921 Thomas Blanton, Texas, unparliamentary language.

    1979 Charles Diggs, Michigan, payroll fraud.

    1980 Charles Wilson, California, receipt of improper gifts, ghost employees, improper personal use of campaign funds.

    1983 Gerry Studds, Massachusetts, sexual misconduct with House page.

    1983 Daniel Crane, Illinois, sexual misconduct with House page.

    2010 Charles Rangel, New York, misuse of official resources in fundraising, filing misleading financial disclosure reports, failure to pay taxes on rental income, using a residential-only, subsidized apartment for a campaign office.


    1976 Robert Sikes, Florida, use of office for personal gain, failure to disclose interest in legislation.

    1978 Charles Wilson, California, false statement before ethics committee investigating Korean influence matter.

    1978 John McFall, California, failure to report campaign contributions from Korean lobbyist.

    1978 Edward Roybal, California, failure to report campaign contributions, false sworn statement before ethics committee investigating Korean influence matter.

    1984 George Hanson, Idaho, false statements on financial disclosure form.

    1987 Austin Murphy, Pennsylvania, ghost voting (allowing another person to cast his vote), maintaining on his payroll persons not performing official duties commensurate with pay.

    1990 Barney Frank, Massachusetts, using political influence to fix parking tickets and influence probation officers for a personal friend.

    1997 Newt Gingrich, Georgia, allowing a member-affiliated, tax-exempt organization to be used for political purposes, providing inaccurate and unreliable information to the ethics committee.

    2009 Joe Wilson, South Carolina, interrupting the president's remarks to a joint session of the House and Senate, which was found to be a "breach of decorum and degraded the proceedings of the joint session."