Man Gets 50 Years to Life in Prison in NYC Elevator Steak Knife Stabbing Death of 6-Year-Old Boy - NBC New York

Chief Investigative Reporter Jonathan Dienst on crime, corruption and terrorism.

Man Gets 50 Years to Life in Prison in NYC Elevator Steak Knife Stabbing Death of 6-Year-Old Boy

6-year-old Prince Joshua "PJ" Avitto died after being stabbed 11 times in the elevator; his best friend, 7-year-old Mikayla Capers, was stabbed 16 times but survived

    processing...

    NEWSLETTERS

    Man Gets 50 to Life for Stabbing Kids in Elevator

    The man who was convicted of stabbing two young children in an elevator in a public housing complex in 2014, killing one of them, was sentenced Tuesday to 50 years to life in prison, prosecutors said. Lori Bordonaro reports.

    (Published Tuesday, May 22, 2018)

    What to Know

    • Daniel St. Hubert was found guilty last month in the elevator stabbing death of 6-year-old Prince Joshua "PJ" Avitto

    • Avitto's best friend, 7-year-old Mikayla Capers, was stabbed 16 times, but survived and testified in the trial against St. Hubert

    • St. Hubert was sentenced Tuesday to 50 years to life in prison

    The man who was convicted of stabbing two young children in an elevator in a public housing complex in 2014, killing one of them, was sentenced Tuesday to 50 years to life in prison, prosecutors said.  

    Daniel St. Hubert, 31, was found guilty last month of murdering 6-year-old Prince Joshua "PJ" Avitto inside an elevator at the Boulevard Houses complex in Brooklyn on June 1, 2014. Avitto's best friend, 7-year-old Mikayla Capers, was also brutally stabbed but survived -- and was able to testify against him.

    "Sometimes I try not to remember this bad man," Capers testified on the stand Tuesday. "Every day, I look at my body, I see 16 stab wounds." 

    "If I wasn't brave for PJ, the man would never be put away," she said. 

    Parolee Found Guilty in NYC Elevator Stabbing of Little Boy

    [NY] Parolee Found Guilty in NYC Elevator Stabbing of Little Boy

    The man who stabbed two young children in an elevator in a public housing complex in 2014, killing one of them, has been found guilty. Gus Rosendale reports.

    (Published Wednesday, April 11, 2018)

    St. Hubert had been living in a homeless shelter at the time of the attack. Police say he pulled out a 9-inch steak knife and started stabbing the two children after telling them to shut up.

    Avitto was stabbed 11 times. Capers was stabbed 16 times. 

    St. Hubert refused to apologize during sentencing, ranting: "I told you, I never killed those kids." 

    His lawyer had argued at trial that his client was framed. He called the surviving elevator victim and witness "a pathological liar."

    Brooklyn District Attorney Eric Gonzalez said in a statement, "This defendant committed an unspeakable crime when he attacked two defenseless young children for no reason, killing one and leaving the other seriously injured.

    "Today's sentence ensures that he will not be able to harm any other innocent people. I know that PJ's loved ones will never be consoled and that Mikayla, whose courageous testimony helped to obtain this conviction, will forever carry this tragedy with her. But I hope that they will find some solace by knowing that justice was done."

    Parolee Convicted in Elevator Stabbing Death of NYC Boy

    [NY] Parolee Convicted in Elevator Stabbing Death of NYC Boy

    The man who stabbed two young children in an elevator in a public housing complex in 2014, killing one of them, has been found guilty in a jury trial, officials say. Gus Rosendale reports.

    (Published Tuesday, April 10, 2018)

    St. Hubert was also convicted of second-degree murder in the jury trial. 

    "It was the right sentence," PJ's mother, Aricka McClinton, said after the sentencing. "The judge brought down a monster like that, never needs to walk the streets nowhere." 

    She said of Capers, "Now maybe Mikayla can live a normal life best she can. Prince can now rest in peace."  

    "I don't ever have to see his face again, and he can't hurt anyone," said Capers. 

    The slaying spotlighted a lack of surveillance cameras in many of NYCHA's over 2,500 buildings, with de Blasio blasting "unacceptable bureaucracy" at a housing agency that had had funds to pay for cameras.

    Ten days after Prince's death, the agency began installing cameras in the Boulevard Houses and some other complexes, ultimately adding them in 49 developments in a year.

    Funeral Held for 6-Year-Old Brooklyn Boy Stabbed in Elevator as Suspect Sits in Jail

    [NY] Funeral Held for 6-Year-Old Brooklyn Boy Stabbed in Elevator as Suspect Sits in Jail
    Hundreds of New Yorkers, some crying and others wearing photo-emblazoned T-shirts, gathered Friday to mourn the 6-year-old Brooklyn boy stabbed to death in a public housing project elevator. Andrew Siff reports.
    (Published Friday, June 6, 2014)

    Get the latest from NBC 4 New York anywhere, anytime

    • Download the App

      Available for IOS and Android