vaccine mandate

‘One Rule for All': FDNY Unions Demand Mayor Lift Vaccine Mandate for All City Workers

Facing full-court pressure from critics, Adams on Friday emphasized that he was simply closing a loophole from the last administration

NBC Universal, Inc.

A day after New York City Mayor Eric Adams doubled down on his controversial decision to lift the city's vaccine mandate for professional athletes and performers, but not city workers, FDNY unions demanded a meeting to discuss the contradiction in policy.

The heads of two firefighter unions delivered a request of the mayor Saturday to sit down within a week's time to discuss the city's vaccine mandate. Presidents of the Firefighters Association and FDNY-Fire Officers Association placed an "emergency" call hoping Adams would reconsider his new order and expand the mandate lift to all city employees.

Currently, somewhere between 400 and 500 firefighters remain unvaccinated and are at risk of losing their jobs with the city, Firefighters Association President Andrew Ansbro estimated. Each week, anywhere from 5 to 10 firefighters receive an ultimatum to get a COVID-19 vaccine or step down, he said.

"When [Adams] was candidate mayor, or mayor-elect, he told de Blasio to sit down with the unions. Now it's his turn to follow through on what Bill de Blasio did," Ansbro said during a virtual press conference. "Mayor Adams, please sit down with us."

The executive order that exempts New York City-based professional athletes and performers from the private sector COVID vaccine mandate means that Brooklyn Nets star Kyrie Irving, who has been outspoken about his decision to not get vaccinated, will be able to take the floor in at the Barclays Center on Sunday.

"We're applauding the mayor's actions of letting the children go back to school without masks, of rolling back the mandate for performers and athletes, but we insist that it be extended to the people that work in New York City, for New York City," Uniformed Fire Officers Association President Jim McCarthy said.

According to the presidents, approximately 15 firefighters have been terminated since the implementation of the mandate, while many more opted for retirement.

"As the mayor says, the science changes. If you're gonna force people to get vaccinated because the science changes, you also have to acknowledge that you're allowing people to have exceptions because the science changes and it's no longer necessary. So, one rule for all," Ansbro said.

Facing full-court pressure, Adams on Friday emphasized that he was simply closing a loophole from the last administration, which prevented hometown athletes from playing home games if they weren't vaccinated — but allowed unvaccinated visiting players to still participate.

"You may consider this a double standard. I consider it an analysis that I made and I'm comfortable with my decision," Adams said at a press conference.

Many are considering the new changes a double standard in the city's vaccination policy, claiming there are different rules for wealthy athletes and performers, and another set of rules for everyone else. NBC New York's Adam Harding reports.

News of Adams' intentions drew swift backlash, with many calling it unfair that city workers, many of whom worked through the pandemic when there was no vaccine available, remain suspended without pay for refusing the doses while millionaire performers get a pass.

The city's teachers union told NBC New York that "If the rules are going to be suspended, particularly for people with influence, then the UFT and other city unions are ready to discuss how exceptions could be applied to city workers."

"This is a step away from following sensible public health-driven policies that prioritize equity,” said City Council Speaker Adrienne Adams, who is not related to the mayor.

In response to her comments, the mayor said that "there are things the City Council speaker will do that I will disagree with, but she has a role in city council, I have a role as mayor."

The city suspended numerous public employees -- about 1,500 of them -- for refusing to get vaccinated, including public servants like firefighters and sanitation workers. All employers are supposed to bar unvaccinated workers from being in shared workplaces. Adams said Thursday he has no plans now to rehire them.

“There can’t be one system for the elite and another for the essential workers of our city," said Harry Nespoli, chair of the Municipal Labor Committee, an umbrella group of unions that together represent about 350,000 city workers.

There are many critics of Mayor Eric Adams' move to end the city's vaccine mandate for professional athletes and performers, saying millionaire athletes are getting a pass while workers lost their livelihoods over the same issue. NBC New York's Gilma Avalos reports.

Adams declared his a "tough" decision done as one of economic necessity and in the best interest of New York's recovery from the pandemic. Adams has seemed prepared for the controversy that began to brew Wednesday.

"I'm mayor of the city and I"m going to make some tough choices. People are not going to agree with some of them," Adams said Thursday. "I was not elected to follow. I was not elected to be fearful but to be fearless. I must move this city forward."

"I'm not making this decision loosely or haphazardly," Adams said. "The city has to function. Some will boo us, others will cheer us -- that is not only a game of baseball but that's the game of life and we have to be on the field in order to win."

Adding NYC-based performers, including outspoken unvaccinated ones like Irving, who has had to remain on the sidelines at home while playing away, to the exempt list is an equalizer, the mayor insisted, and economic booster.

"By putting our home teams on an equal playing field we increase their chances of winning and that has a real impact on this city. It's not just fans in the stands, it's fans in the stores," Adams said Thursday, arguing each home playoff game is worth millions in impact. "These are real dollars and they play a major role."

The amended exemption to the private sector vaccine mandate is effective immediately. In addition to Irving being allowed to play this weekend, the change allows any unvaccinated Met to take the home field on Opening Day next week. The Yankees will be able to do the same after their away series to open the season.

Brooklyn residents react to Kyrie Irving's decision to not get vaccinated. John Chandler reports.

Adams said the change only applies to a "small number" of people, since most have complied with the vaccine mandate. He didn't say how many -- and he sought to make it clear he believes vaccination is the right course for everyone, including Irving.

Adams has reiterated his "peel-back-the-layers" approach to COVID restrictions, citing this latest announcement as another layer in the process. Many are outraged.

What about the janitors and ushers who serve Barclays Center, some have asked. What about the NYPD and FDNY, which had among the lowest vaccination rates citywide before the initial rollout of the mandate, leading to protests and sickouts? And what about the average private worker who has been suspended without pay?

Asked just days ago, Adams said he had no plans to reevaluate the private-sector mandate just yet, calling the workplace an "important environment." He said he was following the science and that baseball and basketball "would have to wait."

Called out about that Thursday, the mayor said, "Two days is still a wait." He also said he had wanted to change the rule when he first took office but his medical team advised against it, given skyrocketing omicron infections across the country.

The creation of special exemptions for athletes or entertainers could potentially lead to court challenges arguing the city isn't applying the law evenly.

Contact Us