I-Team: Thieves Are Swiping NYC's Trash Cans, And It's Not Clear Why

What to Know

  • At least 20 trash cans have been stolen in Manhattan since Feb. 13, according to authorities

  • The thieves were caught on camera lugging away at least one of the hulking, 275-pound bins on a recent Friday

  • A motive in the thefts isn't yet clear; Scrap metal resellers said the bins would only net about $22 apiece

The latest theft spree in New York City is proving that crime can truly be a dirty business.

The I-Team has learned that, for reasons that still aren’t entirely clear, thieves have swiped at least 20 trash bins installed by business improvement districts, charities and other organizations around Manhattan since Feb. 13. The bizarre caper has garnered the attention of the NYPD’s grand larceny division, which is looking for both the people responsible and a motive in the case.

The cans, which are not the rodent-resistant and solar-powered bins that have begun to pop up around the city in recent years, retail for about $1,000 apiece, weigh 275 pounds and have been stolen from corners on the Upper West Side, Upper East Side, Flatiron District and midtown, according to the NYPD.

Surveillance footage from one of the thefts, near Lincoln Square, shows two men struggling to steal the heavy can -- trash still inside -- and load it into the back of an unmarked box truck.

Top Tri-State News Photos

It's not clear why the thieves are stealing the bins. They could also be selling them for scrap -- but scrap metal experts said they'd probably have to destroy them first, because most resellers wouldn’t accept something as obviously stolen as a New York City trash can out of risk of losing their licenses. And even if they did manage to sell them, the thieves would only net about $22 per can.

The thefts garnered incredulity from New Yorkers who are stumped by the reasoning behind the crimes.

“I can’t imagine why anyone would want a filthy dirty garbage can and what they would use it for?” one person asked.

Marlene Verderosa added, “You know, in New York, anything’s possible.”

Still, the thefts are having real-world consequences. The Doe Fund, which employs homeless people to sweep the streets, said its workers have had to walk further to find places to dump the litter they’ve cleaned up. George McDonald, the fund's founder, added that some of the cans installed by the fund have been among those stolen.

“They’re in the van, and boom they’re onto the next one,” said McDonald. “It takes a lot of nerve to do something like that.”

He added, with a chuckle, “Can larceny. It’s unbelievable.”

Anyone with information about the thefts should call Crime Stoppers at 1-800-577-TIPS.