Judge Overturns Probable Cause Finding Against Chris Christie in George Washington Bridge Case, But Won't Toss Complaint - NBC New York
I-Team InvestigationsGeorge Washington Bridge Scandal
2 Ex-Christie Aides Convicted


Judge Overturns Probable Cause Finding Against Chris Christie in George Washington Bridge Case, But Won't Toss Complaint

State Superior Court Judge Bonnie Mizdol denied requests from the governor's attorneys to dismiss the complaint and ordered a municipal court to hold a new hearing



    Judge Overturns Probable Cause Finding Against Chris Christie in George Washington Bridge Case, But Won't Toss Complaint
    AP Photo/Mel Evans, File

    What to Know

    • Wayne resident William Brennan's complaint says Christie violated the official misconduct statute when he failed to reopen lanes on the GWB

    • A different judge ruled in October there was probable cause for the complaint to proceed

    • Christie's attorney had said the complaint should be tossed for procedural violations and lack of evidence

    A New Jersey judge on Thursday ordered a new hearing on a criminal misconduct complaint against Republican Gov. Chris Christie in the George Washington Bridge lane-closing scandal, ruling that a lower court wrongly found probable cause for the case to proceed. 

    State Superior Court Judge Bonnie Mizdol reversed the municipal court finding of probable cause and sent the case back to the lower court for a new hearing on the issue. In her ruling, Mizdol also refused a request from Christie's attorneys to dismiss the citizen's complaint entirely. 

    The complaint, filed by former Teaneck firefighter William Brennan, accuses Christie of failing to act to reopen the lanes that were ordered closed in an alleged political revenge plot to punish a mayor who didn't endorse Christie in 2013. 

    Two of Christie's former aides were convicted in federal court in November. 

    Mizdol agreed with arguments from Christie's attorneys that the lower court's October finding of probable cause was flawed because they weren't allowed to participate or cross-examine Brennan. She found that oversight "was a violation of fundamental constitutional safeguards." 

    But in turning down the request for dismissal, she rejected their arguments that the evidence Brennan offered — testimony from the recent federal trial — wasn't sufficient for a probable cause finding. 

    The scandal dogged Christie through his failed campaign for the GOP presidential nomination, and was considered a factor in his not being chosen as running mate for Donald Trump last year. 

    In the trial, Christie's former deputy chief of staff, Bridget Kelly, said that during the four days of lane closures in September 2013, she told Christie about Fort Lee Mayor Mark Sokolich's concerns that the traffic jams were some form of political payback. 

    Christie's response was to "let Wildstein handle it," referring to David Wildstein, the former Port Authority of New York and New Jersey official who pleaded guilty in the scandal. 

    Christie has publicly denied knowing about the scheme until months later. 

    NJ Judge to Hear Citizen's Complaint Against Gov. Christie

    [NY] NJ Judge to Hear Citizen's Complaint About Gov. Christie in GWB Scandal
    A judge will hear arguments in a citizen's complaint against Gov. Christie in the George Washington Bridge lane-closing scandal. The citizen claims Christie violated the state's misconduct statue by not ordering the lanes to be reopened in 2013.
    (Published Wednesday, Nov. 30, 2016)

    Kelly and Bill Baroni, one of Christie's top appointees to the Port Authority, were convicted of wire fraud, civil rights offenses and misapplying Port Authority property. 

    Christie attorney Craig Carpenito argued that Wildstein's testimony in the federal trial didn't show Christie knew about the motive behind the closing of access lanes to the bridge in September 2013. 

    Wildstein testified he and Baroni told Christie about the traffic jams at a Sept. 11 memorial event in New York and that Christie laughed and made a sarcastic comment when told the mayor of Fort Lee wasn't getting phone calls for help returned. 

    Brennan argued that the law doesn't even require a complainant to testify at a probable cause hearing and that in some instances a judge doesn't even have to hold a hearing to determine if probable cause exists for a case to go forward. 

    Mizdol has previously rejected Brennan's motion to have a special prosecutor appointed to the case, ruling that he didn't have the authority to make that request. Brennan argued that the entire state attorney general's office, as well as each county prosecutor's office in New Jersey, would have a conflict of interest because they owe their jobs to Christie. 

    Official misconduct is punishable by a potential prison term of five to 10 years upon conviction. Before Christie could face a criminal trial, prosecutors would have to collect evidence and present it to a grand jury, which would have to hand up an indictment.

    Get the latest from NBC 4 New York anywhere, anytime

    • Download the App

      Available for IOS and Android