Suspected Ponzi Schemer Surrenders to FBI

FBI says Cosmo may have cheated clients out of $100 million

View Comments (


    Nicholas Cosmo, third from left, turned himself into authorities Monday night.

    The owner of a Long Island investment firm accused of cheating people out of more than $100 million is expected to appear in court Tuesday.

    FBI spokesman Jim Margolin says Nicholas Cosmo surrendered at a U.S. Postal Inspection Service office in Hicksville on Monday night.

    Cosmo runs Agape World Inc. in Hauppauge. He's accused of taking in $300 million from investors and cheating them out of about $140 million.
    A letter hanging in Cosmo's office window denies there was any Ponzi scheme, the type of fraud Bernard Madoff is accused of committing. A Ponzi, or pyramid, scheme promises unusually high returns and pays early investors with money from later investors.

    Cosmo Turns Himself In

    [NY] Cosmo Turns Himself In
    A man accused in what investigators think might be another Ponzi scheme turned himself in Monday night.

    "Right now, I think I've been scammed,"' Richard Bennett, 55, a Valley Stream real estate investor who invested $30,000 with Agape World, told Newsday.

    Unlike Bernard Madoff, who is accused of bilking wealthy individuals and nonprofits, Agape World investors are more ``blue collar and they invested their life savings,'' Michael Kessley, a forensic accountant hired last year to investigate the firm, told Newsday.

    Defense attorneys at the Herrick Feinstein law firm haven't returned telephone calls seeking comment.