Judge Rules 5-Year-Old Girl Can Be Sued for Bike Accident

View Comments ()



    Liberty of London Ladies Garla Second Edition Bicycle

    She might have been too young for grade school, but a judge says a New York City girl was old enough to be sued over a bicycle accident that happened when she was 4.

    A Manhattan judge refused earlier this month to toss out negligence claims against young Juliet Breitman. She, her mother and others are being sued by the estate of a woman who said she was severely hurt when hit by bicycles that Juliet and a boy were racing down a sidewalk in April 2009.

    The woman, Claire Menagh, died later that year.

    Juliet was three months shy of 5. The judge says there's no evidence a child of that age couldn't appreciate "the danger of riding a bicycle into an elderly woman."

    Lawyers for everyone involved didn't immediately return calls for comment.