NBC New York /

News

Israeli, Palestinian Supporters Rally in NYC Several police officers were injured during scuffles at another Palestinian demonstration a few blocks away

Updated 8:00 AM EDT, Mon, Jan 12, 2009

Related Topics: Israel

5 Comments   Post a comment Post a Comment

Demonstrators in Washington
AP

Demonstrators protest against the continuing Israeli offensive in Gaza, Friday, Jan. 2, 2009, in Washington.

 

Thousands of supporters of Israel rallied near the United Nations on Sunday to declare that the Jewish state's two-week-long military action in the Gaza Strip is an act of self-defense.

"For the last three and a half years, Israel's been bombarded daily by a number of rockets coming from Gaza,” said Gov. David Paterson, one of a dozen elected officials who addressed the crowd that filled a block of 42nd Street in Manhattan. "The founding charter of Hamas calls for the obliteration of the state of Israel.”

Across town at Times Square, about 150 pro-Palestinian demonstrators waved signs with pictures of dead and wounded children and chanted, "No justice, no peace! Israel out of the Middle East.”

Several police officers were injured during scuffles at another Palestinian demonstration a few blocks away.

More than 800 Palestinians have died in the Israeli offensive, which began Dec. 27 in an attempt to halt years of Palestinian rocket attacks.

Militants from Hamas, the elected leadership in Gaza, launched barrages of rockets Sunday at the Israeli city of Beersheba and at the town of Sderot.

Partisans of the two sides blamed the other side at their New York rallies.

What country would be asked not to defend itself?” Sen. Charles Schumer asked the pro-Israel rally. "Would any country that had rockets launched at it day after day, week after week, month after month, year after year be told, 'Let the rockets continue? Just sit down and talk?”'

Demonstrators wore red baseball hats in solidarity with Israelis who go on red alert at rocket attacks and chanted, "Israel yes, Hamas no!”

At the smaller pro-Palestinian rally in Times Square, Lebanese-American Bassem Nassar said Israel "is creating the situation that allows people to fire missiles at them” by occupying Palestinian territory.

"The occupation has to end,” he said. "If the occupation ends, they have a right to defend themselves, just like any other country has the right to defend itself.”

Scuffles between supporters of each side erupted at a demonstration a few blocks north after someone stomped on a Palestinian flag, police said.

Seven officers who intervened were hurt in the melee, they said. Ten people were arrested.

Copyright Associated Press

Comments (5)

Sort by: Most Recent | Oldest
  • Chad Tuesday, Jan 13 at 4:15 PM FLAG COMMENT Why do they want to fire up the Arabs more than they are by counter prostesting? If disenfranchized people want to do this then fine. But right now the IDF has the upper hand. Ecclesiastes 9:17 says that the quite words of a wise man are better than the shout of the leader of fools. Also, Proverbs 26:17 says that if you throw your self in as a third party to someone elses fight it is like grabbing a dog by the ears. T ... MORE >
  • cf Monday, Jan 12 at 9:32 PM FLAG COMMENT Agreed JL. I'm tired of such biased coverage. To even equate the two rallies is ridiculous. Two separate stories should have been filed. The rally to support Israel had singing and dancing and a feeling of unity and joy. Thousands gathered and no one was hurt. On the contrary, police officers were thanked for their service. The pro-Hamas rally, which is what it was since anyone who supports Hamas clearly does not support t ... MORE >
  • Richard Shane Monday, Jan 12 at 6:12 PM FLAG COMMENT SS, what's the purpose of Hamas' firing thousands of bombs the past few years? What is the objective?
  • SS Monday, Jan 12 at 3:45 PM FLAG COMMENT Actually JL, the violence started after a pro-Israel protestor physically took a Palestinian flag out of the hands of a Palestinian protestor. Please get your facts straight. Secondly, though I am not a Hamas supporter, they absolutely DO NOT shoot missiles from any civilan building--these are all purely allegations by the IDF; not a single person from the UN backed up that claim. Meanwhile, the Israeli army indiscriminately b ... MORE >
  • JL Monday, Jan 12 at 10:52 AM FLAG COMMENT End the biased reporting! At the Israel rally there were thousands of peaceful gatherers in support of Israel and its action of self defense while the Palestinian rally, with only 150 people ended in violence. How about a little more coverage and explanation for the Israel gathering which included the entire NY assembly and congress. How about some media mention of the fact that Hamas shoots their missiles from inside civil ... MORE >

Post a Comment

Name


Comment - You have 2000 characters left

Enter both words below, separated by a space, in the field located to the lower right. Can't read the words below? Try different words or an audio captcha. What's this?