Coleman Files Appeal | NBC New York

Coleman Files Appeal



    Al Franken vs. Norm Coleman: These two are in the never-ending battle to become Minnesota's next senator.

    Norm Coleman’s legal team has filed an appeal to the Minnesota Supreme Court, contesting his resounding defeat last week at the hands of a lower court in the seemingly endless Minnesota Senate race recount.

    Coleman’s appeal to the state supreme court was expected, but it comes after a week of pressure from Democrats, Minnesota media and even some Gopher State Republicans for him to concede. Coleman and his attorneys have dismissed these calls for his concession, and he has the full backing of Washington Republicans, who continue to raise money for his legal fees in the ongoing fight.

    Coleman’s appeal comes the same day Democrat Al Franken went into senator-elect mode, announcing the hiring a state director to handle Minnesota constituent matters. Franken’s move was as administrative as it was political – he wants maximum pressure on Coleman to step aside in what some legal observers believe is a long shot effort to overcome Franken’s 312 vote lead.

    The premise of Coleman’s state Supreme Court appeal is consistent with what he has contended throughout the six month ordeal – there were 4,400 rejected ballots, and he wants a new review of the ballots in question.

    “We do believe the district court got it wrong on the law, because the Minnesota tradition in law is to franchise people and their decision disenfranchises people whose votes were wrongly discarded,” Coleman attorney Ben Ginsberg said in an afternoon conference call. “Different rules were used by different jurisdiction to create an equal protection violation.”

    Ginsberg said Coleman is “just thinking about the Minnesota Supreme Court,” but even if they lose again, Republicans are pushing for a federal court appeal, which could take months.